Eyebrows are raised and curved, eyes are widened, and the jaw drops open without tension.
Creates oblique eyebrows, often associated with sadness or worry
Creates arched eyebrows, often seen in surprise
Widens eye appearance, shows more of the eyeball
Passive movement from muscle relaxation
Surprise is a brief reaction to the unexpected. The key difference from fear is the lack of tension; there is no Brow Lowerer (AU 4) or Lip Stretcher (AU 20).
These are the most commonly confused expressions because both involve wide eyes and an open mouth.